by Dave Akers, IHSA
“A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.“ – Ancient Chinese proverb, Lao Tzu
Most of us have heard this (translated) Ancient Chinese proverb, but the Chinese have adopted this ancient proverb. The essential concept of this proverb is that huge goals must be broken down into smaller, manageable parts and that it can be applied to all aspects of a person’s life. It also means that when looking at the end goal of a major project, it seems impossible, but it highlights the power of taking the initiative and achieving the goal by taking consistent small actions rather than focusing on the enormity of a long-term goal.
China has done a masterful job of geographically placing industries in different “economic zones” so that they have the skilled resources and experience in specific industries and suppliers surrounding the production facilities. They have situated product designers, engineers, model makers, safety experts, quality control specialists, mold makers and production (brick and mortar) facilities, skilled and unskilled assemblers, supply chain managers and packaging designers. All being in close proximity to economic zones and industries. It is perhaps the most efficient supply and resource chain the world.
China’s Growing Footprint in Mexico: A New Dynamic for Nearshoring and U.S.-China Trade Relations
The landscape of global manufacturing and supply chains is undergoing a significant transformation. As companies increasingly explore nearshoring strategies to mitigate risks associated with distant supply chains and geopolitical tensions, Mexico has emerged as a prime beneficiary. Interestingly, China, often seen as the manufacturing rival, is playing an increasingly prominent and complex role in this shift, establishing a growing presence in Mexico to serve the North American market and eventually perhaps all of the Americas. This article explores the implications of China’s expansion in Mexico for nearshoring efforts, the U.S. market, the reduction of reliance on Chinese manufacturing, and the broader geopolitical context, particularly in light of the current pause in U.S.-China trade issues.
The Rise of “China-in-Mexico” Manufacturing
Driven by the desire to circumvent U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods, reduce shipping times and costs, and capitalize on Mexico’s proximity to the U.S. market and its favorable trade agreements (such as the USMCA United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement), Chinese companies are investing heavily in manufacturing facilities south of the border. This phenomenon, sometimes dubbed “China-in-Mexico” or “near-nearshoring,” sees Chinese firms establishing operations that produce goods intended for U.S. consumers, often with Mexican labor and some local content.
Pros and Cons for the U.S. Market and Reducing Reliance on China
Pros:
- Diversified Supply Chains: For U.S. companies, sourcing components or finished goods from Chinese-owned factories in Mexico can still offer a degree of supply chain diversification away from mainland China. This could reduce the vulnerability to disruptions specifically tied to Chinese domestic policies or geopolitical events directly impacting China.
- Reduced Lead Times and Logistics Costs: Manufacturing in Mexico significantly shortens shipping distances and times compared to China, leading to faster delivery, lower transportation costs, and greater responsiveness to market demands. This can enhance the competitiveness of products in the U.S. market.
- Potential for Increased North American Content: While Chinese-owned, these factories in Mexico will still contribute to Mexico’s industrial base and employ Mexican workers. Over time, there’s potential for increased use of Mexican-sourced components, further integrating North American supply chains.
Cons:
- Limited Reduction in “Chinese Influence”: The primary goal of reducing reliance on China manufacturing is often to lessen geopolitical and economic dependence. If Chinese companies simply shift production to Mexico, the U.S. is still indirectly dependent on Chinese capital, technology, and corporate decision-making, albeit geographically closer. The “Chinese DNA” of the product remains.
- Erosion of Nearshoring’s Original Intent: The spirit of nearshoring for many U.S. companies is to bring manufacturing closer to home, often to U.S. or allied countries, to foster domestic job growth and secure critical supply chains. The influx of Chinese-owned factories, while geographically near, may not fully align with these broader national interests.
- Intellectual Property Concerns: As with direct manufacturing in China, there could still be concerns regarding intellectual property theft or technology transfer, especially if the operations involve advanced manufacturing processes.
- Complex Rules of Origin: Navigating the rules of origin under USMCA can be complex. While products manufactured in Mexico may qualify for tariff-free access to the U.S, the extent to which they truly reduce reliance on Chinese components or intellectual property will depend on the specifics of their supply chain and compliance with local content rules.
Geopolitical Impact of Continuing Trade Issues:
The current “cool down” in U.S.-China trade, “kicks the can down the road” for a year or so, unless a geopolitical event inserts another layer of complexity and possible “knee jerk” ballistic tariff responses. The recent agreement and resolution of some issues, served to de-escalate tensions, allow for ongoing dialog and provides a temporary reprieve, but doesn’t resolve underlying structural issues or long-term strategic competition.
- Strategic Hedging by China: China’s investment in Mexico can be seen as a strategic hedge against ongoing U.S.-China trade tensions and potential future tariff escalations. By establishing a foothold in Mexico, Chinese firms can maintain access to the lucrative U.S. market regardless of the status of direct trade relations between Washington and Beijing.
- U.S. Dilemma: The U.S. faces a dilemma. On one hand, Chinese investment in Mexico helps create jobs and economic activity in a key regional partner. On the other hand, it complicates efforts to reshore manufacturing to the U.S. and truly decouple critical supply chains from China. The U.S. government will need to carefully consider how to balance its economic relationship with Mexico, its nearshoring objectives, and its strategic competition with China.
- Regional Integration vs. Geopolitical Competition: This trend highlights the tension between regional economic integration and geopolitical competition. While North America seeks to strengthen its own manufacturing ecosystem, Chinese firms are actively inserting themselves into this space, blurring the lines of national origin and control.
- Potential for Future Trade Friction: If the pause in U.S.-China trade issues cause tensions to flare up again, the U.S. might eventually consider measures to address the “China-in-Mexico” phenomenon, perhaps through stricter rules of origin enforcement or even new tariffs on products originating from Chinese-owned factories in Mexico if they are perceived to undermine U.S. national interests.
Conclusion:
China’s expanding manufacturing presence in Mexico is a powerful indicator of the evolving global supply chain landscape. While it offers some advantages for U.S. companies seeking diversified supply chains and reduced logistics costs, it presents a nuanced challenge to the broader goal of reducing reliance on Chinese manufacturing and influence.
About IHSA
Don’t miss out on the significant savings available exclusively to IHA members through your shipper community, the IHSA. From May through April, members save millions on ocean freight costs.
Take advantage of this valuable resource today! Visit the International Housewares Shippers Association website or email team@shippersassociation.org to learn more and start saving.
Member onboarding status for 2025: HOLD
